The Champion

August 2006 , Page 18 

Search the Champion Looking for something specific?

Preview of Member Only Content

For full access: login or Become a Member Join Now

What's the Matter With Illinois? How an Opportunity Was Squandered to Conduct an Important Study on Eyewitness Identification Procedures

By Timothy P. O'Toole

In April 2002, the Illinois Governor’s Commission on Capital Punishment issued a report that sought to identify why Illinois had experienced so many wrongful convictions in capital cases and to propose changes to rehabilitate the criminal justice system of Illinois. One focus was faulty eyewitness testimony. As the Commission noted, “the fallibility of eyewitness testimony has become increasingly well-documented in both academic literature and courts of law.”1 This conclusion was both uncontroversial and understated: Virtually all studies rank mistaken eyewitness identification as the leading cause of wrongful convictions, by one estimate accounting for 88 percent of the erroneous rape convictions and 50 percent of the wrongful murder convictions.2 The Department of Justice itself analyzed 28 DNA exonerations and concluded that inaccurate eyewitness testimony was “the most compelling evidence” in the majority of those cases.3  

Faced with these facts and the many wrongful convictions al

Want to read more?

The Champion archive is reserved for NACDL members.

NACDL members, please login to read the rest of this article.

Not a member? Join now.
Join Now
Or click here to see an overview of NACDL Member benefits.

See what NACDL members say about us.

To read the current issue of The Champion in its entirety, click here.

  • Media inquiries: Contact NACDL's Director of Public Affairs & Communications Ivan J. Dominguez at 202-465-7662 or
  • Academic Requests: Full articles of The Champion Magazine are available for academic and research purposes in the WestLaw and LexisNexis databases.

In This Section

Advertisement Advertise with Us