☰ In this section

The Champion

September 2011 , Page 34 

Search the Champion Looking for something specific?

Preview of Member Only Content

For full access: login or Become a Member Join Now

It's Time to Fix the Federal Criminal System

By John D. Cline

Blackstone famously declared that “it is better that ten guilty persons escape, than that one innocent suffer.”1 In today’s federal criminal system, that idea seems quaint. An acquittal is viewed as a sign the system does not work.2 Efficiency has become the highest value.

The federal criminal system in its current form affords the prosecution so many advantages that even an innocent defendant has little chance of acquittal. A defendant whose guilt is merely doubtful has almost no chance. Once in a great while the defense wins, but only because courageous judges and juries resist the systemic pressure to convict and imprison. 

This article lists ways the system favors the prosecution, from investigation through appeal, and suggests a menu of reforms. The list is not exhaustive — just a few examples among dozens. Encountered in isolation, each imbalance may seem inconsequential. As a whole, they produce a system so heavily stacked for conviction that few defendants dare risk trial. Those

Want to read more?

The Champion archive is reserved for NACDL members.

NACDL members, please login to read the rest of this article.

Not a member? Join now.
Join Now
Or click here to see an overview of NACDL Member benefits.

See what NACDL members say about us.

To read the current issue of The Champion in its entirety, click here.

  • Media inquiries: Contact NACDL's Director of Public Affairs & Communications Ivan J. Dominguez at 202-465-7662 or idominguez@nacdl.org
  • Academic Requests: Full articles of The Champion Magazine are available for academic and research purposes in the WestLaw and LexisNexis databases.
Advertisement Advertise with Us

In This Section

Advertisement Advertise with Us