United States v. Davis
Brief Details
- Case No.: 19-1696
- Brief Filed: April 05, 2021
- Jurisdiction: 3rd Circuit Court of Appeals
Key Topics in the Brief
Briefs
Prior Decision
Panel decision 985 F.3d 298 (3rd Cir. Jan. 12, 2021)
Argument(s)
The panel opinion broadens the definition of “substantial step,” contravening Supreme Court and Circuit precedent and raising constitutional concerns. A “substantial step” is conduct “toward” the commission of the object offense. Davis improperly broadens statutory attempt offenses, with constitutional implications. Requiring a substantial step “toward” the commission of the object offense strikes the right balance between protecting the public and avoiding overcriminalization. Davis’s redefinition of the actus reus for attempt has broad implications.
Author(s)
Lisa A. Mathewson, The Law Offices of Lisa A. Mathewson, LLC, Philadelphia, PA; Carolyn H. Kendall, Post & Schell, P.C., Philadelphia, PA; Mira Baylson and Molly Rucki, Cozen O’Connor, Philadelphia, PA.
