Smalls v. Collins

Brief Of Amici Curiae American Civil Liberties Union, Bronx Defenders, Cato Institute, Center for Appellate Litigation, Center on The Administration of Criminal Law at New York University School Of Law, Legal Aid Society, National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, National Police Accountability Project, New York Civil Liberties Union, New York State Chief Defenders Association, New York State Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, and Office of the Appellate Defender Supporting Reversal.

Brief filed: 07/31/2020

Documents

Smalls v. Collins

2nd Circuit Court of Appeals;

Prior Decision

Decision below 2020 WL 2563393 (E.D.N.Y. Mar. 11, 2020)

Argument(s)

Evidence fabrication is a serious and pervasive problem, and its innocent victims often do not obtain an “indication of innocence.” Requiring indicia of innocence for civil rights claims of evidence fabrication is unfair and unworkable. McDonough does not affect the substantive difference between malicious prosecution claims and fabrication claims, which address corruption of the criminal process regardless of probable cause. The District Courts’ rule would be unjust, unfair, and unworkable. The District Courts’ rule undermines the core accountability function of § 1983 in cases of very serious misconduct. The District Court’s rule would harmfully exacerbate the existing power imbalance against criminal defendants. The District Courts’ rule is not administrable and will yield arbitrary results.

Author(s)

David A. Lebowitz and Douglas E. Lieb, Kaufman Lieb Lebowitz Frick LLP, New York, NY; Joshua L. Dratel and Lindsay A. Lewis, NACDL, New York, NY.

Explore keywords to find information

RECENTLY ADDED & UPCOMING

  1. The Champion
    /Nacdl/media/image_library/StayInformed/Champion/ChampionCovers/March-April-2025.jpg?ext=.jpg

    March/April 2025

    What are the evidentiary implications of field sobriety tests in marijuana cases? Does the odor of marijuana give officers probable cause to search a vehicle?

  2. Amicus Brief
    /Nacdl/media/image_library/Elements/global/amicus.png

    Jenner & Block LLP v. U.S. Department of Justice

    Brief of the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers and New York Council of Defense Lawyers as Amici Curiae in Support of Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment.

  3. News Release
    /Nacdl/media/image_library/Elements/global/newsrelease.png

    News Release ~ Law Enforcement Executive Order

    NACDL Warns Executive Order's Dangerous Overreach Undermines Community Safety and Trust in Police – Washington, DC (April 29, 2025) – The National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers (NACDL) expressed deep concern regarding the Executive Order titled "Strengthening and Unleashing America’s Law Enforcement to Pursue Criminals and Protect Innocent Citizens," cautioning that several of its proposals represent a dangerous overreach that undermines these goals by jeopardizing individual rights and the legitimacy of law enforcement in the eyes of the community.

  4. Event
    /Nacdl/media/image_library/Learn/nacdlcleinstitute/2025_Post-Dobbs_Trial_Tactics_2025-02-26_v02_Event-Listing_2.jpg?ext=.jpg

    Trial Tactics for Pregnancy-Related Cases: Skills for Every Defender

    LOCATION: The University of Texas School of Law, Austin, TX
    DATE: May 16-17, 2025
    COST: FREE (registration is required)
    CLE Credit: Up to 14.5 credits 

  5. Webinar
    /assets/img/nacdl_og.png

    Collaborative Approaches to Appellate Defense: Recognizing Clients' Legal Expertise

    WHEN: Thursday, May 8, 3:00-4:30pm ET / 12:00-1:30pm PT
    CLE CREDIT: not available
    COST: Free

Featured Products