NACDL - Buck v. Davis

Buck v. Davis

Brief of Amici Curiae National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers and Texas Criminal Defense Lawyers Association in Support of Reversal.

Brief filed: 08/04/2016

Documents

Buck v. Davis

United States Supreme Court; Case No. 15-8049

Prior Decision

Decision below Buck v. Stephens, 623 Fed.Appx. 668 (5th Cir. Aug. 20, 2015).

Argument

The Fifth Circuit has repeatedly failed to follow this Court's precedent concerning issuance of COA. This Court has clearly articulated the standards for granting a COA. This Court was required to reiterate the standards for issuance of a COA in Miller-El v. Cockrell, 537 U.S. 322 (2003). The errors identified in Miller-El continue to influence Buck's case. The Fifth Circuit's self-created rules tend to impermissibly disfavor the grant of habeas corpus relief. The Fifth Circuit's consideration of COA again required this Court's intervention: In Tennard, 542 U.S. 274, 283 (2004). Despite this Court's stated principles for issuance of a COA, the Fifth Circuit proceeded along "a distinctly different track." Even after Tennard, the Fifth Circuit continued to adhere to its own jurisprudence rather than this Court's precedents. Mr. Buck's case is an appropriate one for this Court to reinforce the correct application of its COA standards in the Fifth Circuit.

Author(s)

Barbara Bergman, NACDL, Tuscon, AZ; Hilary Sheard, TCDLA, Austin, TX.