- Material Indifference: How Courts Are Impeding Fair Disclosure in Criminal Cases
- Material Indifference Executive Summary
- Material Indifference Fact Sheet
In courtrooms across the nation, accused persons are convicted without ever having access to, let alone an opportunity to present, information that is favorable to their defense.
The frequency with which this occurs and the role it plays in wrongful convictions prompted NACDL and the VERITAS Initiative to undertake an unprecedented study of Brady claims litigated in federal courts over a five-year period. The Study asked: What role does judicial review play in the disclosure of favorable information to accused? The results revealed a troubling answer—the judiciary is impeding fair disclosure in criminal cases and, in doing so, encouraging prosecutors to disclose as little favorable information as possible.
- Press Release
- Discovery Reform Page
- Prosecutorial Misconduct Page
- Complete C-SPAN Video of November 17, 2014 Launch Event at National Press Club
- Model Ethical Rule Order
On November 17, 2014, at the National Press Club in Washington, DC, NACDL officially released its latest report, Material Indifference: How Courts Are Impeding Fair Disclosure in Criminal Cases, a major study produced jointly with the VERITAS Initiative at Santa Clara Law School. The event featured comments by NACDL President Theodore Simon, NACDL Executive Director Norman L. Reimer (who also moderated the event), and special guests David W. Ogden, former Deputy Attorney General who is now a partner at the WilmerHale firm, and the Hon. Alex Kozinski, Chief Judge of the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals. The report's co-authors – VERITAS Initiative Director and Professor Kathleen "Cookie" Ridolfi, NACDL White Collar Crime Policy Counsel Tiffany M. Joslyn, and VERITAS Initiative Pro Bono Research Attorney Todd H. Fries –also discussed their findings and recommendations. The event was broadcast live by C-SPAN and is available on demand here.
To receive an electronic copy of the study data please contact NACDL's Director of Economic Crime & Procedural Justice, Nathan Pysno, at 202-465-7627 or firstname.lastname@example.org.
Media inquiries should be directed to NACDL’s Senior Director of Public Affairs & Communications, Ivan J. Dominguez, at 202-465-7662 or email@example.com.