The California Trial Penalty: The Constitutional Right To Trial Under Attack

A Comprehensive Analysis of Causes, Consequences, and Options for Reform in California

Jury trials have nearly vanished in California: just 2.2% of felony convictions now come from trial. A key driver is the “trial penalty,” the gap between the sentence for pleading guilty and the far harsher one for going to trial. This report, from NACDL and CACJ’s Task Force, analyzes ten years of data from more than 1.5 million cases and offers ten recommendations to restore the right to trial. [Released Nov 2026]

The Task Force, a group of pro bono lawyers and data analysts created by NACDL and CACJ in 2021, spent five years studying the problem. It surveyed California defense lawyers and prosecutors and analyzed ten years of sentencing data from more than 1.5 million cases in 14 counties. Nine in ten defense lawyers said defendants are penalized for going to trial, and the data agreed: in most counties with enough data to compare, people convicted of felonies at trial received sentences about three times longer than those who pled guilty, and the gap was often even larger in misdemeanor cases. The trial penalty also chips away at other constitutional rights, since a guilty plea usually means giving up the right to challenge unlawful searches or coerced statements, and it limits the public’s ability to see how courts and prosecutors do their jobs. None of this is inevitable. It is the result of choices made at every level of government, and the report’s ten policy recommendations show how those choices can be changed.

The California Trial Penalty

Learn more about NACDL’s Trial Penalty Work

News Release

Nation’s Criminal Defense Bar: The Constitutional Right to Trial is Under Attack in California (Nov. 19, 2026)

Featured Products

Explore keywords to find information