☰ In this section

The Champion

Current Issue , Page 60 

Search the Champion Looking for something specific?

Preview of Member Only Content

For full access: login or Become a Member Join Now

Supreme Court: Garza v. Idaho: Preserving the Client’s Choice to Appeal

By Craig Durham, Jonah Horwitz, Brian McComas, and Lauren M. Weinstein

Read more Supreme Court columns.

The decision to appeal a conviction always lies with the client. But what is a defense attorney to do when the client pleads guilty, signs an appeal waiver, and then wishes to appeal after sentencing? The U.S. Supreme Court recently provided the answer in Garza v. Idaho1: Obey the client and file a notice of appeal.

Gilberto Garza, Jr. signed two plea agreements containing waivers of his rights to appeal and was sentenced according to the terms of those agreements.2 After sentencing, however, he wanted to appeal and told his attorney as much. Garza’s trial counsel responded that “‘an appeal was problematic because he waived his right to appeal in his Rule 11 agreements.’”3 He disregarded Garza’s instructions and did not file a notice of appeal, forfeiting Garza’s opportunity for direct appellate review.4 

Persisting, Garza filed a petition for postconviction relief, arguing that his attorney was ineffective for failing to notice his appeal.5 The lower courts denied the petition.6 The Ida

Want to read more?

The Champion archive is reserved for NACDL members.

NACDL members, please login to read the rest of this article.

Not a member? Join now.
Join Now
Or click here to see an overview of NACDL Member benefits.

See what NACDL members say about us.

To read the current issue of The Champion in its entirety, click here.

  • Media inquiries: Contact NACDL's Director of Public Affairs & Communications Ivan J. Dominguez at 202-465-7662 or idominguez@nacdl.org
  • Academic Requests: Full articles of The Champion Magazine are available for academic and research purposes in the WestLaw and LexisNexis databases.
Advertisement Advertise with Us

In This Section

Advertisement Advertise with Us